Heyo, top 5 Friday is back! It’s still technically Thursday for a few more hours, but my Friday is going to be largely occupied because I am going hiking! My Aussie friend Elysia and I are attempting a 20 km Rundweg (though based on things like time, fatigue, etc. we might just opt to do the 10 km one-way trail) in the Schwarzwald. I’m super pumped, because the a) Schwarzwald is gorgeous, b) the trail is renowned for its waterfalls, and c) my Chacos haven’t gotten nearly the amount of summer loving they’re used to. It’s going to be such a fun day!!!! Also, Elysia and I both have a weakness for ice cream and we have already decided that a 20 km hike warrants a reward of a dairy nature.
ANYWAY, this is yet another double top 5 list, and the topic is university (or, as we Americans call it, college)!
Suffice it to say that I was a little culture-shocked when I got here and started school. I’ve been doing a lot of thinking about the ways the systems in the US and Germany differ and what I like better about each one respectively. (Granted, I know a whole lot more about the American system and am more familiar with it, so therein lies my bias. So be it.)
Top 5 things Germany does better:
1. “Thirst for knowledge” and individual motivation to learn are rewarded and nurtured here a lot more than they are in the US. There is a lot less instruction and a lot more individual study, so if you aren’t excited about learning, you won’t learn too much.
2. Classes are consistently smaller here. Considering that a 300 person lecture is pretty much commonplace at UT, that might not be saying much, but the University I’m at is 20,000 people and lectures are consistently between 40 and 60.
3. The systems for law and medical certification and training are way less complicated. You simply study law or medicine in university (programs which do take a little longer than other bachelor degrees, but not 4 years longer) and then take Staatexamen at the end. Not to say that those tests are easy, but it’s not exactly LSAT>law school>bar.
4. Uni structure forces you to grow up. It’s a lot more like a job here. You go to class, go home, study, cook dinner. Then go to bed, wake up, and do it again.
5. It is way cheaper to attend college here. In fact, only recently did the concept of paying for college make it to Germany, and now it’s a couple hundred Euro per year to enroll. It evens the playing field a bit. (Just a bit though.)
Top 5 things the US does better:
1. There is a didactic structure to college because, gosh darnit, we’re in school and we came here to be taught. When I complained once about less instruction time and less structure, a German student simply commented that uni here is “less didactic.” I don’t think this is necessarily a good thing. It IS good to have the aforementioned passion to learn, but the tenured professors under whom I study at UT have valuable things to teach me, too, and I’m grateful for the structure they provide.
2. Students don’t have to individually worry about as much bureaucratic jargon. Sure, we have to negotiate the red tape of advising, registering, etc., but once we’re enrolled in a class, for instance, there is a set group of pre-dictated credits that you get for passing that class. In Germany, it’s up to you to tell the system what credit you want and then figure out what you need to do to get that credit. You spend more effort figuring out that junk than actually working on the assignments. It’s so backwards.
3. American universities provide a more well-rounded education. Even though I am studying International Relations, I take more than just politics, government, and history classes. I am required to study at least a little science, a foreign language, math, etc. in order to complete my degree. In Germany, you pick your major (and maybe a minor) and basically only take related courses from then on.
4. When the semester is over, it’s really over. You take your tests, turn in your papers, and pack your bags. This semester in Freiburg “ends” (aka lectures end) on August 6. Then, there is a 2 month period for students to write their big papers (Hausarbeit). Fortunately, I don’t have any of those… otherwise, I’d be screwed.
5. College life exists. Sure, students here hang out with their friends and go eat at the restaurants around campus and are in clubs and stuff, but there is no “college life.” I’m sure this differs from university to university, but I’m glad to have had a residence hall-living, football game-attending, school pride-having, American college experience.
I guess you can see where my loyalties lie. But in my opinion the chips fell favorably… I only have to put up with the German system for 4 months… I’m stuck with American higher education for (at least) 2 more years, so I’m glad I have found a new appreciation for it.
Catch you fools later, I have some waterfalls to see! Ciao ciao!